Sunday, November 14, 2010

Weekly Writing 9

Throughout the course I have been researching Andrew Jackson.  I wanted to focus on the nineteenth century.  My original plan was to cover the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries in my thesis.  However, in the last couple of months reality has begun to set in.  If I am going to be a part of the program, I will have to adjust my focus to meet the faculty’s expertise.  I cannot write about the early republic if all my courses are over World War 2.  I am considering a late nineteenth to mid twentieth century focus.  If I were to make this adjustment, I would study a minority group.  I would either study Native Americans in this transitional period; or I would study prostitution and female sexuality during the era.  The two intersect at many points.  I will probably end up with a hybrid topic for my thesis.  For example, I could do a thesis on Native women being forced into brothels during the period.  There are a lot of possible topics to focus on. 
I have looked back at my course plan.  I have decided to make an adjustment.  After a lot of consideration, I decided to extend my plan by one semester.  This would put me on schedule to graduate next spring.  Also, I have already got a professor to agree to be on my graduate committee.  I am still considering who my other two will be, but I have some people in mind.  My history professors frequently serve on graduate committees.   This gives me some confidence.  They should know exactly what they want from me.  So I can start studying early.  So far things seem to be going fine.

Sunday, October 24, 2010

Weekly Writing 8

     So far, my project is coming around well.   I have found more sources at another USF Library (Jane Badcock Libray).  They have a considerable amount of historical sources over President Jackson and his invasion of Florida.  Most are older sources;, however I have obtained some newer books from Poynter Library.  It will be intriguing reading a 1940’s interpretation vs. a more recent one.  I believe that current politics do indeed curve one’s perception of their own history (even by a few decades).
      On a more recent note, I have already started organizing my materials and focusing on how I want to represent the narratives I have from my sources.  Considering that there is a meta-narrative about the subject, I am reluctant to what I will and will not use.  This projected is proving to be very interesting, yet I have to do research within my sources to check the merit and validity each theory and statement I might use for my project.  I believe that this works for narrowing down my materials to what I really need. 
     Overall, I feel like I am doing well in the course and on my research project.  Being busy is the new norm for be now and I am not wasting much time.  However, I would like to learn more about the annotated bibliography.  I have an idea now on how to do it, but I would like some guidance after putting it together myself.

Monday, October 18, 2010

Weekly writing seven

I am doing an annotated bibliography.  My topic is Andrew Jackson's invasion of Spanish Florida in the 19th century.  so far, my interest lies in the motivations for the invasion.  At this time, I am still using my texts in relation to this topic.  The following is a brief draft of my annotated bibliography.

Wilfred T. Neill, Florida’s Seminole Indians (St. Petersburg, Fl: Great Outdoors Publishing Co, 1956), 6-21.
This book is primarily about the Seminoles of Florida. It explains the origin of the tribe and goes into some detail about the invasion of Florida. It brings up a point about black Seminoles. It reminds the reader that the Seminoles’ relationship to runaway slaves was a major part of the First Seminole War. This is the official name of the invasion. This book will be used in references to the social and political reasons for the invasion.
 
Robert V. Remini, Andrew Jackson (New York: Harper & Row, 1969)
This is a biography of Andrew Jackson. It contains information about Jackson’s life. It will be insturmental in evaluating Jackson’s motives and personal opinion of the invasion.

Monday, October 4, 2010

Weekly Writing 6

Preston Roberts
 
This semester I will be researching Andrew Jackson and his invasion of Spanish Florida. I will be researching both the events of the invasion and the motives. The average American has been given the impression that he invaded Florida because of his hatred for Native Americans. I believe this to be an over simplified answer. I intend to research the motives of the invasion including any orders given to him by the state departments and to what extend he was allowed to use his discretion to initiate the invasion. I haven’t found that this is a popular topic for today’s historians. Subsequently, I am not sure who, if anybody, is interested in this issue. My questions for the paper are:
1. Was Andrew Jackson ordered to invade Florida or was it entirely his decision?
2. If he was ordered to invade, what were the motives of the American government in invading Florida?
3. If it was Andrew Jackson’s decision, what were his motives?
4. What was the Spanish reaction?
5. How has the event been branded?
6. What lead to this stigma?
7. Why did Jackson need to invade Florida?
 
These questions relate to my field by addressing the key issues we are expected to cover. In history, knowledge of the event is a pre requisite. It is the first step in the writing process. After reading about what happened, we ask how and why it happened. My plan is to give an annotated bibliography over my topic. I have a nice selection of books so far. I will be working primarily with biographies of Andrew Jackson and James Monroe. There are also several primary sources I will be dealing with. For example, There are a number of letters Jackson wrote home from the field. I am still looking for a compete set of them for citation sake before I list them. There are also documented reactions from Jackson’s political opponents.
These are some of my sources so far:
1.The Black Seminoles By Kenneth Porter
2. Florida’s Seminole Indians by Wilfred Neill
3. When Men Grew Tall: The Story of Andrew Jackson by Alfred Lewis
4. Andrew Jackson By Robert Remini
5. On to Pensacola; Retracing the Trail Andrew Jackson Onced Blazed across West Florida By Elba Carswell
Because I am doing an annotated bibliography, my timeline will be rather loose. Rather than focusing on what day I will have my sources on, I will just continue to search for new sources and annotate them as the year progresses.
 

Monday, September 27, 2010

Weekly Writing 5

     This weeks readings were interesting.  They had to do with marginalized groups.  Dr McCracken's work, Street Sex Work: Re/Constructing Discourse from Margin to Center, she looks into how we as a society look at prostitutes.  She shows that the media not only reflects our cultures view of prostitutes but, in many ways, they also dictate it.  It was clear that a lot of work went into researching this article.  I enjoyed it.
     Philip Zwerling's article, Right on the Border: Mexican-American Students Write Themselves Into The(ir) World, is about a community writing class the author designed for underprivileged students at a small rural college.  Instead of just giving them simple grammar lessons, he teaches them how to engage the community through writing.  One way or another the students would have to improve their writing to participate.  It was an interesting look at how a good professor can help students.
     Week by week, our understanding of research is evolving.  While I have been doing this kind of research for years as an undergrad, I never took the time to break it down the way we are doing this semester.  It does get tedious, but we are probably lucky to have this kind of opportunity early in the program.

Monday, September 20, 2010

Weekly Writing 4

The first sample of history I will talk about is Hugh Lee's article The Halma: A Running or Standing Jump?.  The Halma was an event in the ancient Greek Olympics.  Lee uses examples from literature and paintings to recreate the event.  A runner would have two weights in his or her hand that he or she would jog with.  As he or she jumped, he or she would thrust the weights forward to gain momentum.  then he or she would drop them before they could weigh him or her down.  The author did extensive research and the theories are well supported by evidence.  The problem is the evidence is based on interpretation of art and literature.  This can lead to inconsistencies.
     The next article I will discuss is Dr. Ward-Smith's article The application of modern methods of biomechanics to the evolution of jumping performance in ancient Greece.  Dr Ward-Smith is writing about the same event.  A jumper named Phayllos is said to have leaped 55 feet.  Dr. Ward Smith uses calculus and physics equations based on the record long jumpers of the modern era to calculate different scenarios that could permit a person to travel this far.  None of them are plausible and many would be dangerous.  He suggests that the Halma was more like our triple jump than a long jump.  That would explain the long distances.
     These sources are interesting and they represent the variety of research in my field nicely.  Although they both examine the same subject, they take different approaches and represent their conclusions appropriately.

Sunday, September 12, 2010

Weekly Writing 3

Research is pretty straight forward. It is gathering as much information as possible about a topic and using it to provide awnsers to questions. In my field, which is history, research can look a bit different but it is still the same. For example, within my focus of American history, I study Native Americans. A great deal of my research time will be spent on learning Spanish and French. In the field of history, we are typically expected to read all sources in the original language. So my research begins with learning to read these 16th and 17th century versions of foriegn languages and then I'll be qualified to start analyzing sources. I am not sure what my research projects will be yet. I have three this semester. Two of them are for history classes and one will be in this course. I am still looking in to some topics.

Monday, September 6, 2010

Weekly Writing 2

I have not had much success in making my course map.  I am unaware of the courses available to me in the coming years.  I have an idea how it will go.

Fall 2010
8 hours of history and a required MLA course

Spring 2011
8 hours of history and a required MLA course

Summer 2011
4 hours of history and required MLA course/courses

Fall 2011
6 hours thesis and any remaining MLA requirements

I have not been able to identify what professors I want to be on my committee. There are a limited number of historians on campus and their CV's are not on their websites. It will take some time for me to get to know them and then, once I have a better understanding of their respective research areas, I will be able to make a more informed decision regarding this issue.

Week 2 in class writing

I have been considering my research project for a few days now.  I will be doing a history project, as that is my focus.  I intend to find a topic dealing with Native American history.  The annotated bibliography option looks attractive, especially considering I already have two other large research projects this semester.  I am also considering preparing a conference presentation.  I think this would be a good experience.  but as a history major, my comfort zone is in writing a long paper about a topic.  I will have to decide after I select my topic.

Friday, September 3, 2010

Weekly Writing 1

     This weeks reading consisted of several parts. The first was Rhetoric: An Overview. As the title implies, this was essentially a definition paper on Rhetoric. It explains what rhetoric is and how it fits into writings. In the reading, rhetoric is defined as "the art of persuasion." It identifies the three important elements of an argument as purpose, audience, and context. Purpose is the authors motivation for writing the work. The audience is the specific group the author is addressing. Context is the circumstances surrounding the author and audience. This was a clear and concise section.
     The next part is entitled Obama, Oprah, Yo' Mamma: A Personal Essay On Rhetorical Analysis. In this essay, Jason Thompson identifies the three rhetorical appeals authors use to present there argument. Ethos is the ethical appeal. It stresses credibility. Pathos is an emotional appeal. Logos is an appeal to logic. This appeal includes both sound logic and logical fallacies. This essay was very well written. It explained rhetorical appeals very effectively.
     The next reading was The Nature Of Rhetorical Criticism. This piece was not so much about defining rhetoric as much as explaining the value of recognizing it. In this work, rhetoric includes all active human engagements that project symbols. For example, the new Freedom Tower will be a building and a symbol. Because of this, it will be rhetorical. Everything humans do can usually be tied to symbols. The author explains how understanding the intended symbols helps us to better appreciate the work of these people. This was well written as well. It was a little less clear than the previous two sections. Overall, it was a very good supplement to the other works that did a much better job of identifying rhetoric.

Day 1 in class writing

The reason I applied to the MLA program was because it is a step towards my ultimate career goal. My final goal is to be a History professor at a university. After completing this degree I will be applying to a Doctoral program in history. I am excited about being able to satisfy my history requirements while at the same time, using other departments as a way of rounding out my education to avoid too narrow of a view. My studies here will make the most difference in the world after I graduate. As a professor, it will be these courses I draw on to ensure my classes are both insightful and accurate. This is obviously very important. Tomorrow’s prodigies are only as good as the professors who design their curriculums.




I can only assume that this class is about research and protocol. I imagine we will be going over proper research methods and the proper way to present topics at the graduate level. If this is the case, it can only help me down the road as both a master’s and doctoral student. My primary concern about the class is the class itself. As I hinted above, I am not sure what to expect and I can only hope I will be good at it. Because I took the risk of seeking an alternate master’s degree rather than going for history, my GPA is even more vital for my success than some other students. Despite this, I still feel I made the right choice. As an MLA student, I can take classes that grade and refine my writing style as opposed to merely the content. In history courses, Style is second to the accuracy of your statements. That is why I wanted to be able to take writing courses that focus entirely on how to write rather than what you are writing about.