Monday, September 20, 2010

Weekly Writing 4

The first sample of history I will talk about is Hugh Lee's article The Halma: A Running or Standing Jump?.  The Halma was an event in the ancient Greek Olympics.  Lee uses examples from literature and paintings to recreate the event.  A runner would have two weights in his or her hand that he or she would jog with.  As he or she jumped, he or she would thrust the weights forward to gain momentum.  then he or she would drop them before they could weigh him or her down.  The author did extensive research and the theories are well supported by evidence.  The problem is the evidence is based on interpretation of art and literature.  This can lead to inconsistencies.
     The next article I will discuss is Dr. Ward-Smith's article The application of modern methods of biomechanics to the evolution of jumping performance in ancient Greece.  Dr Ward-Smith is writing about the same event.  A jumper named Phayllos is said to have leaped 55 feet.  Dr. Ward Smith uses calculus and physics equations based on the record long jumpers of the modern era to calculate different scenarios that could permit a person to travel this far.  None of them are plausible and many would be dangerous.  He suggests that the Halma was more like our triple jump than a long jump.  That would explain the long distances.
     These sources are interesting and they represent the variety of research in my field nicely.  Although they both examine the same subject, they take different approaches and represent their conclusions appropriately.

2 comments:

  1. Hi Preston,

    Isn’t it fun for Historians to look waaay back at how the world operated in common aspects like sports and daily living? First, I’d like to know the source of these articles. Then, based on your first sample, do you believe that a person can move further with weights in their hands as described? Would it really give them momentum?

    In reference to your second article, did the ancient Greeks use the same standard of measurement that we use today? Did their concept of 55 feet match ours? It would be interesting to find a modern take on both of your articles. Thanks for sharing and inspiring the questions in my mind!

    Angela

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anytime I read article like this I have to wonder...unless there is some left over weights how do they know what they did? I'm tryng to picture what it would be like to run down the field with weights in my hand....I have a hard time walking with weights in my hand that are rather light I couldn't imagine running!

    ReplyDelete